Page MenuHomeSchine - Phabricator

Starmade | FBO INIT error on world load
Closed, FinishedPublic

Description

Starmade crashes with the message "Runtime:FBO FAILED TO INIT" when loading into a world on mac. It happens at 99% for singleplayer worlds and 29% for multiplayer. Hitting retry displays the message "GLException: GL_INVALID_FRAMEBUFFER_OPERATION". Hitting retry on the second dialog cycles back to the first error.

Details

Task Type
Bug
Testing Results
Affected Gamemode(s)
Single and Multi
Reproducible
Yes
Last tested (version)
0.201.129
Category
none/unspecified
First occurrence (version)
0.201.126
Hardware/Software/System
OS-Specific
OSX Only
Hardware-Specific
Video (GPU)
Video Card Vendor
NVIDIA
Video Card Model
NVIDIA GeForce GT 750M
Steps to reproduce

Release Version 0.201.126 - 0.201.129
macOS 10.13.5 (17F77)
MacBookPro11,3
NVIDIA GeForce GT 750M
Also occurs when forced to use Intel Iris Pro on same machine.
Also occurs on Macmini6,2

Launch game, attempt to load world.

Detected video (Graphicsinfo.txt)

File does not exist ("mdfind Graphicsinfo.txt" returned nothing)

SMC-Report

Not apparently available on macOS

Serverconfig (server.cfg)
 <WORLD = unset //set world to use (set 'old' for using the old world). if no world exists a new one will be set automatically
PROTECT_STARTING_SECTOR = false //Protects the starting sector
ENABLE_SIMULATION = true //Universe AI simulation
CONCURRENT_SIMULATION = 256 //How many simulation groups may be in the universe simultaniously (performance)
ENEMY_SPAWNING = true //Enables enemy spawing
SECTOR_SIZE = 2000 //Sets the size of sectors in the universe **WARNING** scaling the size of an existing universe down may cause issues
BLUEPRINT_DEFAULT_PRIVATE = true //If true, set blueprints private as default (else they are public)
FLOATING_ITEM_LIFETIME_SECS = 240 //How much seconds items floating in space should be alive
SIMULATION_SPAWN_DELAY = 420 //How much seconds between simulation spawn ticks
SIMULATION_TRADING_FILLS_SHOPS = true //Trading guild will deliver stock to shops
SECTOR_INACTIVE_TIMEOUT = 20 //Time in secs after which sectors go inactive (-1 = off)
SECTOR_INACTIVE_CLEANUP_TIMEOUT = 10 //Time in secs after which inactive sectors are completely removed from memory (-1 = off)
USE_STARMADE_AUTHENTICATION = false //allow star-made.org authentication
REQUIRE_STARMADE_AUTHENTICATION = false //require star-made.org authentication (USE_STARMADE_AUTHENTICATION must be true)
PROTECTED_NAMES_BY_ACCOUNT = 10 //How many player names a player may protect with his account (if exceeded, the player name, that was logged in the longest time ago gets unprotected)
DEFAULT_BLUEPRINT_ENEMY_USE = true //Default option for blueprints not in catalog yet
DEFAULT_BLUEPRINT_FACTION_BUY = true //Default option for blueprints not in catalog yet
DEFAULT_BLUEPRINT_OTHERS_BUY = true //Default option for blueprints not in catalog yet
DEFAULT_BLUEPRINT_HOME_BASE_BUY = true //Default option for blueprints not in catalog yet
LOCK_FACTION_SHIPS = true //If true, ships of other factions cant be edited, activated, or entered
CATALOG_SLOTS_PER_PLAYER = -1 //How many slots per player for saved ships (-1 for unlimited)
UNIVERSE_DAY_IN_MS = 1200000 //how long is a 'day' (stellar system rotation) in milliseconds (-1 to switch off system rotation)
ASTEROIDS_ENABLE_DYNAMIC_PHYSICS = true //enables asteroids to be able to move in space
ENABLE_BREAK_OFF = false //debug (don't activate unless you know what you're doing)
COLLISION_DAMAGE = false //colliding into another object does damage
COLLISION_DAMAGE_THRESHOLD = 2.0 //Threshold of Impulse that does damage (the lower, the less force is needed for damage)
SKIN_ALLOW_UPLOAD = true //if off, skin uploading to server is deactivated
CATALOG_NAME_COLLISION_HANDLING = false //if off, saving with an existing entry is denied, if on the name is automatically changed by adding numbers on the end
SECTOR_AUTOSAVE_SEC = 300 //Time interval in secs the server will autosave (-1 for never)
PHYSICS_SLOWDOWN_THRESHOLD = 40 //Milliseconds a collision test may take before anti-slowdown mode is activated
THRUST_SPEED_LIMIT = 75 //How fast ships, etc. may go in m/s . Too high values may induce physics tunneling effects
MAX_CLIENTS = 32 //Max number of clients allowed on this server
SUPER_ADMIN_PASSWORD_USE = false //Enable super admin for this server
SUPER_ADMIN_PASSWORD = mypassword //Super admin password for this server
SERVER_LISTEN_IP = all //Enter specific ip for the server to listen to. use "all" to listen on every ip
SOCKET_BUFFER_SIZE = 65536 //buffer size of incoming and outgoing data per socket
PHYSICS_LINEAR_DAMPING = 0.05 //how much object slow down naturally (must be between 0 and 1): 0 is no slowdown
PHYSICS_ROTATIONAL_DAMPING = 0.05 //how much object slow down naturally (must be between 0 and 1): 0 is no slowdown
AI_DESTRUCTION_LOOT_COUNT_MULTIPLIER = 0.9 //multiply amount of items in a loot stack. use values smaller 1 for less and 0 for none
AI_DESTRUCTION_LOOT_STACK_MULTIPLIER = 0.9 //multiply amount of items spawned after AI destruction. use values smaller 1 for less and 0 for none
CHEST_LOOT_COUNT_MULTIPLIER = 0.9 //multiply amount of items in a loot stack. use values smaller 1 for less and 0 for none
CHEST_LOOT_STACK_MULTIPLIER = 0.9 //multiply amount of items spawned in chests of generated chests. use values smaller 1 for less and 0 for none
USE_WHITELIST = false //only names/ips from whitelist.txt are allowed
FILTER_CONNECTION_MESSAGES = false //don't display join/disconnect messages
USE_UDP = false //Use 'User Datagram Protocol' (UDP) instead of 'Transmission Control Protocol' (TCP) for connections
AUTO_KICK_MODIFIED_BLUEPRINT_USE = false //Kick players that spawn modified blueprints
AUTO_BAN_ID_MODIFIED_BLUEPRINT_USE = false //Ban player by name that spawn modified blueprints
AUTO_BAN_IP_MODIFIED_BLUEPRINT_USE = false //Ban player by IP that spawn modified blueprints
AUTO_BAN_TIME_IN_MINUTES = 60 //Time to ban in minutes (-1 for permanently)
REMOVE_MODIFIED_BLUEPRINTS = false //Auto-removes a modified blueprint
TCP_NODELAY = true //Naggles algorithm (WARNING: only change when you know what you're doing)
PING_FLUSH = false //flushes ping/pong immediately (WARNING: only change when you know what you're doing)
SHOP_SPAWNING_PROBABILITY = 0.1 //(must be between 0 and 1): 0 is no shops spawned in asteroid sectors, 1 is shop spawned in everyone (default: 8% -> 0.08)
DEFAULT_SPAWN_SECTOR_X = 2 //DEFAULT Spawn Sector X Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_SECTOR_Y = 2 //DEFAULT Spawn Sector Y Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_SECTOR_Z = 2 //DEFAULT Spawn Sector Z Coordinate
MODIFIED_BLUEPRINT_TOLERANCE = 0.1 //Tolerance of modified blueprint trigger (default = 10%)
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_X_1 = 8.0 //First Rotating Spawn: Local Pos X Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Y_1 = -6.5 //First Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Y Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Z_1 = 0.0 //First Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Z Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_X_2 = 15.0 //Second Rotating Spawn: Local Pos X Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Y_2 = -6.5 //Second Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Y Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Z_2 = 8.0 //Second Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Z Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_X_3 = 8.0 //Third Rotating Spawn: Local Pos X Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Y_3 = -6.5 //Third Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Y Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Z_3 = 15.0 //Third Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Z Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_X_4 = 0.0 //Forth Rotating Spawn: Local Pos X Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Y_4 = -6.5 //Forth Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Y Coordinate
DEFAULT_SPAWN_POINT_Z_4 = 8.0 //Forth Rotating Spawn: Local Pos Z Coordinate
PLAYER_DEATH_CREDIT_PUNISHMENT = 0.1 //players credits lost of total on death (must be between 0 and 1): 1 = lose all, 0 = keep all
PLAYER_DEATH_CREDIT_DROP = false //drop credits lost on death into space instead
PLAYER_DEATH_BLOCK_PUNISHMENT = false //player will drop all his blocks into space on death
PLAYER_DEATH_PUNISHMENT_TIME = 300 //Time interval in seconds after death of a player in which the player is not punished
PLAYER_HISTORY_BACKLOG = 30 //How many login history objects (with name, IP, account-name, and time) should be saved by player state
PROJECTILES_ADDITIVE_VELOCITY = false //initial projectile speed depend on relative linear velocity of object fired from
PROJECTILES_VELOCITY_MULTIPLIER = 1.0 //multiplicator for projectile velocity
WEAPON_RANGE_REFERENCE = 2000.0 //Reference distance for weapon ranges. (what blockBehaviorConfig.xml weapon ranges are multiplied with (usually the sector size)). Set to 1 to interpret weapon ranges in the config in meters
ALLOW_UPLOAD_FROM_LOCAL_BLUEPRINTS = true //enables clients being able to upload their pre-build-blueprints to the server
SHOP_NPC_STARTING_CREDITS = 10000000 //how much credits do shops start with
SHOP_NPC_RECHARGE_CREDITS = 100000 //how much credits do shops gain about every 10 min
AI_WEAPON_AIMING_ACCURACY = 10 //how accurate the AI aims (the higher the value the more accurate vs distance. 10 = about 99% accuracy at 10m)
BROADCAST_SHIELD_PERCENTAGE = 5 //percent of shields changed for the server to broadcast a shield synch
BROADCAST_POWER_PERCENTAGE = 50 //percent of power changed for the server to broadcast a power synch (not that critical)
ADMINS_CIRCUMVENT_STRUCTURE_CONTROL = true //admins can enter ships of any faction
STAR_DAMAGE = true //suns dealing damage to entities
SQL_NIO_FILE_SIZE = 256 //megabyte limit of .data file when to use NIO (faster) (must be power of 2)
PLANET_SIZE_MEAN_VALUE = 100.0 //Planet size mean (normal gaussian distribution) (min 50)
PLANET_SIZE_DEVIATION_VALUE = 35.0 //Planet size standard deviation. Note: normal gaussian distribution graph scaled horizontally by 1/3 (min 0)
ASTEROID_RADIUS_MAX = 64 //Asteroid max radius in blocks (from -x to +x)
ASTEROID_RESOURCE_SIZE = 2.5 //Average diameter of resource veins in asteroids
ASTEROID_RESOURCE_CHANCE = 0.003 //Chance per block to place a new resource vein (1.0 = 100%)
PLAYER_MAX_BUILD_AREA = 10 //max area a player may add/remove in adv. build mode
NT_SPAM_PROTECT_TIME_MS = 30000 //period of spam protection
ASTEROID_SECTOR_REPLENISH_TIME_SEC = -1 //seconds until a sector that is mined down to 0 asteroids is replenished (-1 = never)
NT_SPAM_PROTECT_MAX_ATTEMPTS = 30 //max attempts before refusing connections in spam protect period (default is 1/sec for 30 sec)
NT_SPAM_PROTECT_EXCEPTIONS = 127.0.0.1 //ips excepted from spam control (separate multiple with comma) (default is localhost)
ANNOUNCE_SERVER_TO_SERVERLIST = false //announces the server to the starmade server list so clients can find it. Hostname must be provided for HOST_NAME_TO_ANNOUNCE_TO_SERVER_LIST!
HOST_NAME_TO_ANNOUNCE_TO_SERVER_LIST =  //this must be a valid hostname (either ip or host, e.g. play.star-made.org)
SERVER_LIST_NAME = NoName //max length 64 characters
SERVER_LIST_DESCRIPTION = NoDescription //max length 128 characters
MISSILE_DEFENSE_FRIENDLY_FIRE = true //can shoot down own or missiles from own faction
USE_DYNAMIC_RECIPE_PRICES = true //use recipe based prices (the price is the price of the parts it is made out of in crafting)
DYNAMIC_RECIPE_PRICE_MODIFIER = 1.05 //modifier to adjust dynamic price
MAKE_HOMBASE_ATTACKABLE_ON_FP_DEFICIT = true //Home bases become attackable if a faction's Faction Points are in the minus and the faction doesn't own any territory
PLANET_SPECIAL_REGION_PROBABILITY = 240 //one out of thisValue chance of a special region spawning per planet plate (cities, pyramids, etc) (changing this value migth change some plates, but won't change any plates that are already modified by a player)
NT_BLOCK_QUEUE_SIZE = 1024 //How many blocks are sent per update. Huge placements will shot faster, but it will consume more bandwidth and is subject to spamming players
CHUNK_REQUEST_THREAD_POOL_SIZE_TOTAL = 10 //Thead pool size for chunk requests (from disk and generated)
CHUNK_REQUEST_THREAD_POOL_SIZE_CPU = 2 //Available threads of total for CPU generation. WARNING: too high can cause cpu spikes. About the amount of available cores minus one is best
BUY_BLUEPRINTS_WITH_CREDITS = false //buy blueprints directly with credits
SHOP_USE_STATIC_SELL_BUY_PRICES = false //shop buy and sell price change depending on stock (shop prices will always stay the same if true)
SHOP_SELL_BUY_PRICES_UPPER_LIMIT = 1.2 //maximum of base price a shop will want depending on its stock (e.g. max 120 credits if the normal cost is 100)
SHOP_SELL_BUY_PRICES_LOWER_LIMIT = 0.8 //minimum of base price a shop will want depending on its stock (e.g. max 80 credits if the normal cost is 100)
MINING_BONUS = 1 //general multiplier on all mining
MAX_LOGIC_SIGNAL_QUEUE_PER_OBJECT = 250000 //max logic trace queue allowed
MAX_LOGIC_ACTIVATIONS_AT_ONCE_PER_OBJECT_WARN = 10000 //warn about objects that activate more than x blocks at once
MAX_LOGIC_ACTIVATIONS_AT_ONCE_PER_OBJECT_STOP = 50000 //stop logic of objects that activate more than x blocks at once. They will enter a logic cooldown of 10 seconds to prevent servers from overloading
MAX_COORDINATE_BOOKMARKS = 20 //coordinate bookmarks per player allowed
ALLOWED_STATIONS_PER_SECTOR = 1 //How many stations are allowed per sector
STATION_CREDIT_COST = 50000 //how much does a station or station blueprint cost
SKIN_SERVER_UPLOAD_BLOCK_SIZE = 256 //how fast should skins be transferred from server to clients (too high might cause lag) [default 256 ~ 16kb/s]
WEIGHTED_CENTER_OF_MASS = true //if on, the center of mass for each structured will be calculated based on block mass. On 'false', the center of mass is always the core position
SECURE_UPLINK_ENABLED = false //dedicated servers can be registered on the StarMade registry
SECURE_UPLINK_TOKEN =  //uplink token, provided when registering a dedicated server
USE_STRUCTURE_HP = true //ships and other structures use the hitpoint system. if off, a ship will overheat when the core gets taken out (old)
SHOP_REBOOT_COST_PER_SECOND = 100.0 //Cost to reboot a ship at a shop (per second it would take to reboot in space)
SHOP_ARMOR_REPAIR_COST_PER_HITPOINT = 1.0 //Cost to repair a ship's armor at a shop
MAX_SIMULTANEOUS_EXPLOSIONS = 10 //the more the faster explosions at the same time are executed (costs in total about 20MB RAM each and of course CPU because it's all threaded) (10 is default for a medium powered singleplayer)
REMOVE_ENTITIES_WITH_INCONSISTENT_BLOCKS = false //This will remove ships that have blocks that are normally disallowed (e.g. space station blocks on ships)
OVERRIDE_INVALID_BLUEPRINT_TYPE = true //If a loaded blueprint is invalid, it's type will be overridden
FACTION_FOUNDER_KICKABLE_AFTER_DAYS_INACTIVITY = 30 //Days of inactivity after which a founder may kick another founder
BLUEPRINT_SPAWNABLE_SHIPS = true //enables or disables blueprint spawning from item
BLUEPRINT_SPAWNABLE_STATIONS = true //enables or disables blueprint spawning from item
USE_OLD_GENERATED_PIRATE_STATIONS = false //enables spawning of old style pirate stations
CARGO_BLEED_AT_OVER_CAPACITY = false //cargo is ejected every minute if storage is at over capacity
ALLOW_PERSONAL_INVENTORY_OVER_CAPACITY = false //Personal Inventory can go over capacity
ONLY_ALLOW_FACTION_SHIPS_ADDED_TO_FLEET = false //only allows faction ships to be added to fleet
MAX_CHAIN_DOCKING = 25 //maximal deepness of docking chains (may cause glitches depending on OS (path and filename length) at high numbers)
SHOP_RAILS_ON_ADV = true //Advanced shops will have 4 rails dockers that can be used like a neutral homebase (anything docked is safe)
SHOP_RAILS_ON_NORMAL = false //Normal shops will have 4 rails dockers that can be used like a neutral homebase (anything docked is safe)
ALLOW_FLEET_FORMATION = true //Allows fleet formation
BACKUP_WORLD_ON_MIGRATION = true //Back up world when migrating to a new file format
BACKUP_BLUEPRINTS_ON_MIGRATION = true //Back up blueprints when migrating to a new file format
SECTORS_TO_EXPLORE_FOR_SYS = 15 //How many sectors of a system have to be explored
NPC_FACTION_SPAWN_LIMIT = -1 //Maximum npc factions per galaxy (-1 for unlimited (will still be around 2-10))
NPC_DEBUG_MODE = false //Sends complete NPC faction package to clients (very bandwith intensive)
FLEET_OUT_OF_SECTOR_MOVEMENT = 6000 //How long for an unloaded fleet to cross a sector in ms
NPC_LOADED_SHIP_MAX_SPEED_MULT = 0.7 //How fast NPC fleet ships are compared to their max speed when loaded
USE_FOW = true //Use 'fog of war'. Turning this off will make everything visible to everyone
ALLOW_PASTE_AABB_OVERLAPPING = true //Allow Paste bounding box overlapping
DEBUG_FSM_STATE = false //DEBUG_FSM_STATE
PHYSICS_SHAPE_CASTING_TUNNELING_PREVENTION = false //PHYSICS_SHAPE_CASTING_TUNNELING_PREVENTION
FORCE_DISK_WRITE_COMPLETION = false //FORCE_DISK_WRITE_COMPLETION
DEBUG_SEGMENT_WRITING = false //DEBUG_SEGMENT_WRITING
TURNING_DIMENSION_SCALE = 1.1 //TURNING_DIMENSION_SCALE
RECIPE_BLOCK_COST = 5000 //RECIPE_BLOCK_COST
RECIPE_REFUND_MULT = 0.5 //RECIPE_REFUND_MULT
RECIPE_LEVEL_AMOUNT = 4000 //RECIPE_LEVEL_AMOUNT
IGNORE_DOCKING_AREA = false //IGNORE_DOCKING_AREA
ALLOW_OLD_DOCKING_BEAM = false //ALLOW_OLD_DOCKING_BEAM
NT_SPAM_PROTECT_ACTIVE = true //NT_SPAM_PROTECT_ACTIVE
USE_PERSONAL_SECTORS = false //USE_PERSONAL_SECTORS
BATTLE_MODE = false //BATTLE_MODE
BATTLE_MODE_CONFIG = battleSector=0,0,0,Physics.smsec;battleSector=15,15,15,Physics.smsec;countdownRound=300;countdownStart=30;maxMass=-1;maxDim=300;maxMassPerFaction=-1; //BATTLE_MODE_CONFIG
BATTLE_MODE_FACTIONS = [TeamA, fighters, 500,500,500, 0.5,0.1,0.9];[TeamB, fighters, -500,-500,-500, 0.5,0.9,0.2];[TeamFFA,ffa, 0,0,-500, 0.2,0.9,0.9];[Spectators,spectators, 0,500,0,0.8,0.4,0.8] //BATTLE_MODE_FACTIONS
LEADERBOARD_BACKLOG = 24 //LEADERBOARD_BACKLOG
DEBUG_BEAM_POWER_CONSUMPTION = false //DEBUG_BEAM_POWER_CONSUMPTION
DEBUG_BEAM_TICKS_DONE = false //DEBUG_BEAM_TICKS_DONE
DEBUG_BEAM_POWER_PER_TICK = false //DEBUG_BEAM_POWER_PER_TICK
DEBUG_MISSILE_POWER_CONSUMPTION = false //DEBUG_MISSILE_POWER_CONSUMPTION
NPC_LOG_MODE = 0 //NPC_LOG_MODE
NPC_DEBUG_SHOP_OWNERS =  //NPC_DEBUG_SHOP_OWNERS
SQL_PERMISSION =  //SQL_PERMISSION
DEBUG_EMPTY_CHUNK_WRITES = false //DEBUG_EMPTY_CHUNK_WRITES
ALLOWED_UNPACKED_FILE_UPLOAD_IN_MB = 1024 //ALLOWED_UNPACKED_FILE_UPLOAD_IN_MB
RESTRICT_BUILDING_SIZE = 2.0 //RESTRICT_BUILDING_SIZE
DISPLAY_GROUPING_DEBUG_INFORMATION = false //DISPLAY_GROUPING_DEBUG_INFORMATION
MANAGER_CALC_CANCEL_ON = true //MANAGER_CALC_CANCEL_ON
ALLOW_OLD_POWER_SYSTEM = true //ALLOW_OLD_POWER_SYSTEM
JUMP_DRIVE_ENABLED_BY_DEFAULT = true //JUMP_DRIVE_ENABLED_BY_DEFAULT
SHORT_RANGE_SCAN_DRIVE_ENABLED_BY_DEFAULT = true //SHORT_RANGE_SCAN_DRIVE_ENABLED_BY_DEFAULT
SPAWN_PROTECTION = 10 //SPAWN_PROTECTION
AI_ENGAGEMENT_RANGE_OF_MIN_WEAPON_RANGE = 0.75 //AI_ENGAGEMENT_RANGE_OF_MIN_WEAPON_RANGE
>
Clientconfig (settings.cfg)
 <replace this block with the file content, 
but do not remove the first and last line. 
Before using the paste function, mark the area from the 
opening angle bracket to the closing angle bracket>
Java Version (32bit)

Error: This Java instance does not support a 32-bit JVM.
Please install the desired version.

Java Version (64bit)

java version "1.8.0_131"
Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.8.0_131-b11)
Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (build 25.131-b11, mixed mode)

Event Timeline

OrbitalHippie changed Reproducible from uncertain to Yes.
lancake added a subscriber: lancake.Aug 9 2018, 3:42 PM
lancake changed the task status from Open to In Queue.
lancake claimed this task.

Fixed in a hotfix.

Restricted Application removed a project: Issue Navigation. · View Herald TranscriptAug 9 2018, 3:42 PM
lancake shifted this object from the S1 Public space to the S3 Starmade space.Aug 9 2018, 3:42 PM
lancake changed the visibility from "Custom Policy" to "Public (No Login Required)".
lancake changed the edit policy from "Task Author" to "Starmade (Project)".
lancake changed the task status from In Queue to Resolved.
lancake raised the priority of this task from Normal to High.
Restricted Application added a project: Quality Assurance. · View Herald TranscriptAug 9 2018, 3:42 PM
Restricted Application added a subscriber: AndyP. · View Herald Transcript
lancake closed this task as Closed.Aug 9 2018, 3:42 PM
Restricted Application removed a project: Quality Assurance. · View Herald TranscriptAug 9 2018, 3:42 PM
Restricted Application removed a subscriber: AndyP. · View Herald Transcript