The kick button for members inside the faction tab is missing and you are unable to kick people from the faction
Description
Description
Details
Details
- Commits
- Restricted Diffusion Commit
Restricted Diffusion Commit
Restricted Diffusion Commit
Restricted Diffusion Commit
Restricted Diffusion Commit
Restricted Diffusion Commit
Restricted Diffusion Commit - Task Type
- Bug
Testing Results
- Affected Gamemode(s)
- Single and Multi
- Reproducible
- Yes
- Last tested (version)
- 0.19357 (Dev)
- Category
- Ingame GUI/HUD
- First occurrence (version)
- 0.1932
Hardware/Software/System
- OS-Specific
- No
- Hardware-Specific
- No
- Video Card Vendor
- Other
| Status | Assigned | Task | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unknown Object (Maniphest Task) | ||||
| Closed | None | T415 Unable to kick members out of faction |
Event Timeline
There are a very large number of changes, so older changes are hidden. Show Older Changes
This comment was removed by SmilingDemon.
This comment was removed by SmilingDemon.
Comment Actions
more related to T388 ... maybe now only a non founder with the right to kick may do so?
Comment Actions
the Kick button is back but there is a small problem
Kicking isnt working ... everyone is considered founder in this regard
Comment Actions
Kick /Promote /Demote tested with 3 Members in Faction
All did work as i would expect
can find only one flaw
If a Character has Promote/Demote rights he cant modify other members of the same rank or himself (Which is OK!) but the Buttons to do so are still shown in that case (only they do nothing)
I on the other hand can Kick a Member of my own rank
Comment Actions
I am still not convinced this works right.
2 Members with the same rank and Kick/invite/promote rights are not able to Demote/Promote each other
- thats correct and drops a warning about too low of a rank to do so.
- but you still can Kick someone of the same rank ... why should i by unable to demote them but kicking works?
- after i did kick the member in that fashion its name stayed in the Members list, but the player was from his side without a faction. reinvite fixed that. And beeing kicked again by the founder did remove him from the list properly than
Comment Actions
Note, this is from micdoodle8c's perspective
I'm not able to kick (or even see the kick button) for players of the same rank. Are you sure you haven't edited the roles to allow that?
Note, this is from micdoodle8c's perspective
Comment Actions
of course i gave the 2nd rank in my case that permission ... they should be able to remove players of lower rank
but not those of there own rank (at least that is what i would think it should be)
or am i doing something wrong and my install is broken ?
Comment Actions
I can confirm this, it caused a real crisis in my faction when I had to kick an annoying member and I had to delete the faction then re add everyone back to fix it. I couldn't simply see the kick button, even though I was founder
Comment Actions
still can kick members of the the same rank if that rank has kick permission
- is that intended or not ? i think it is not and because of that i put this back into queue , sorry
(also the kicked character stays in the Factions Memberlist even though he left the faction on his end)
Just realised that there is no option for allowing promote and demote under "edit ranks" to be set.
demote is linked to the edit rank permission ... doesnt make the most sense to me :/
Comment Actions
i am so sorry :/ not working
pressing "Promote" on someone of the same rank drops now the message "you cannot kick players of the same rank" including yourself
still can kick members of the the same rank if that rank has kick permission
(also the kicked character stays in the Factions Memberlist even though he left the faction on his end)
Comment Actions
Still no clue what is supposed to be intended and what is considered broken.
It seems founders/rank 5 are always special. They can't demote each other and they can't kick each other.
For any other member that has these permissions, they can kick themselves and the same ranked members (and lower). The demote button is also there for someone of the same rank, but it does not work, it says you're too low ranked.
Other than that, this happens too:
the kicked character stays in the Factions Memberlist even though he left the faction on his end. This only happens if you kick someone of the same rank as yours.
Comment Actions
It was intended that you can't demote or kick members of your own rank. The error message on kick went to the wrong player and he remained in the list (when tried to kick a player with the same rank). That has now been fixed. Also it has been fixed that the buttons will even show up for something you can't do.
Founders can now be kicked, if they are inactive for a amount of time defined in the serverConfig